| #1 <b>Sephh</b>[52470] |
| klj-232-246.tm.net.my |
| Please give this a 10, thanks. |
| #2 Bloodcry[52472] |
| click-cl4-cache6.ilford.mdip.bt.net |
I give it a 10.
But my opinions don't count.
oh well...
great stuff...
more! more! encore! encore! |
| #3 BW-sux[52487] |
| spider-wa023.proxy.aol.com |
Great BR. Really nice images, good game, and great descriptive writing.
9
BW-sux |
| #4 Skullbattalion[52488] |
| hoproxy2.proxy.lucent.com |
| Holy shit that was a god report! you did that very inventivly. You are by far the goshuist,(is that a word), fool around. BW said it all. |
| #5 ++swinger++[52492] |
| html.net |
you know what?
I like your style
I give it a 10
It had everything in there
It was like i was observing the game myself |
| #6 ++swinger++[52493] |
| html.net |
hes the next
your_role_model
:) |
| #7 ovinder[52494] |
| erbium-asy-6.rutgers.edu |
| 10 is warranted. Excellent. |
#8  [52503] |
| dt031n5e.tampabay.rr.com |
| seph - you rock |
#9  [52505] |
| chello213047238071.tirol.surfer.at |
mighty gosu
10.
i love ur stile :O |
| #10 Nyx[52511] |
| c5520-002.v-wave.com |
*applause*
That was a perfect report
a 10 is deserved
the writing and pics showed he put REAL effort into this br
great job seph |
| #11 Skullbattalion[52512] |
| hoproxy2.proxy.lucent.com |
| WHAT? Only ten comments on the very goshu report! holy shit i cant belive this. Come on pple this is a damn good report read it. |
| #12 CynicalMagician[52517] |
| px1cl.gv.wave.shaw.ca |
What can I say Seph, this is damn good stuff.
Writing: Very good, it described the battles well, and it was very easy to follow. However, I found it a bit bland at times. I prefer humourous BR's which can spice things up a bit, but whatever.
Images: Nice stuff, Plenty of minimap updates, pretty text, what more do you want?
Appearance: Very cool, it looks like it's a navbar for a page or something. I like it. Good font size and readability too.
Overall: This is an excellent report. Keep it up.
-CynicalMagician |
| #13 Kane-[52518] |
| ftmadisonagent.lisco.net |
Sephh=god
That's all there is to it ;) |
| #14 Sephh[52519] |
| klj-228-148.tm.net.my |
Bob and Necro, you guys rock more :)
I didn't do humour mainly because of two things :
i) I suck at it
ii) Humour is very subjective, one one person might think as very funny might not even make another smile. :|
Maybe someone should help me out with humour. Strat heavy battlereports rock:) |
| #15 Hiso[52522] |
| proxy2-external.santab1.ca.home.com |
WoW this really does deserve a 10.. this your first report??
|
| #16 Sephh[52524] |
| klj-228-148.tm.net.my |
| Hiso : Nope, my second. :) |
#17  [52526] |
| inehou-pxy05.compaq.com |
The report was great, but Kak only had 2 expansions =[ I am surprised the whole map wasn't his!!! >=] This report is great, but not groundbreaking.
9
Fox^1 |
| #18 ++swinger++[52530] |
| html.net |
what the hell happened to your_role_model?
he stop making reports or something
the latest report i can remember of him was that World War 3
ne1 know what happened to him?
he was like my hero
but now hes like my old legend in some book in the attic that is covered in dust |
#19  [52533] |
| 208.196.35.239 |
The graphics rocked, the writing was good, the game was good, Kak was good.
1on1s on Temple don't get 10's anymore though. That theme has been beaten to death.
Still enjoyed the read though, keep up the good work<i>!!</i>
9
Cheers,
Dref |
| #20 Talon[52536] |
| cx110054-a.pwy1.sdca.home.com |
kak has this weird ability to always come back from games he is losing to win.
This game.
PvT vs Fox^1
ZvZ vs Me
ect. ect.
It's really pretty gay :( |
| #21 Blade|IcE|[52540] |
| c790560-a.smateo1.sfba.home.com |
the only reason it wasnt given a 10, in my opinion, is that:
A-1v1 Temple (although very entertaining) is nothing new
B-the title gave away the winner (it was soooooo obvious)
great writing style, and i like strat heavy reports more than humor, humor is gay =P somtimes its good but most are homo sorry guys
Strat heavy reports own (like heartcutters reports)
Blade |
| #22 CraZy[52542] |
| 24.65.122.105.sk.wave.home.com |
| yah you homo kak you always drop my main then im screwed :[ |
| #23 [52546] |
| inehou-pxy05.compaq.com |
Dam you Talon did you have to bring up that game!!!! STUPID FERRYING GOONS #($&(#*(#*@$& WHATEVER!!!!!!!!!
Fox^1
|
| #24 Marie47[52550] |
| 1Cust235.tnt5.minneapolis.mn.da.uu.net |
| Kewl :D |
| #25 ChinksWithGuns[52553] |
| adsl-63-193-153-8.dsl.lsan03.pacbell.net |
I disagree that this report deserved two tens. Sure it was good... but definitely not 10 material. If compared to other 10s, its not even close. Maybe I'm just bitter because I've never gotten a 10 and this is his 2nd report and ALREADY getting a 10. And swinger, please stop calling him Your_Role_Model. You're making him look like Bob_the_Newt. And God Himself knows no one would like to be in any way related to bob. And also, he's on a team making their own RTS. Maybe if you looked at the main page of br.com under the news, you'd know.
-Chinks |
| #26 Hi[52560] |
| spider-th013.proxy.aol.com |
| Chinks is a very bitter about having a small penis, too... |
| #27 Sexy^Orangutang[52566] |
| spider-tm084.proxy.aol.com |
| that kicked ass |
| #28 [52578] |
| dt031n5e.tampabay.rr.com |
ive made chinks a lean, mean aye-shun machine.
i like it! |
| #29 <font color=yellow> |]agomar[52586] |
| static-30.itcanada.com |
One word:
<b>GOSU!</b>
This was an excellent report, a 9 for sure! WTG, and on yor second br too! G O S U
:oD |
| #30 Slayangel[52595] |
| pool0182.cvx9-bradley.dialup.earthlink.net |
Good report. Not top of the line though. The perfect report pleases on every level... humor, strategy, pics/animation. If you feel your report is good you can ask for special consideration, but to use first comment to ask for a 10 is pretentious.
If your report is strat heavy, see if you can add a joke or two to lighten it up. If it is mostly pics and flash, thicken up the written content.
This report needed some humor, maybe including some repartee from the participants or characterizations for the units. Also, don't do Temple if you want a top notch report. Temple is the BGH of starcraft elitists. While I never tire of learning about Temple strategies don't expect a Temple report to really stand out.
Download Bob's maps on this site's news page and come up with something really creative. You have the potential to earn what you're asking for... you're just not there yet.
~Slay
P.S. Poor Chinks... :[ |
| #31 Hiso[52598] |
| proxy1-external.santab1.ca.home.com |
| You guys are all just jealous:( btw NOONE on this site has ever used good enuf humour to make me laugh out loud ( well maybe drefsab) mostly a bunch a homo jokes, sarcasm and silly puns;( so maybe a report doesn't need "humour", strats are something many people don;t do tho... |
| #32 Dr.3vil[52609] |
| 98AFE1FB.ipt.aol.com |
| EXCELLENT BR! ... but one suggestion: try to add a little more humor, that's what makes Drefsab the creame of the reporting crop. |
| #33 Fractal_Wave[52620] |
| 24.65.21.53.bc.wave.home.com |
Really really really nice.....Me likey
All the best,
Fractal_Wave |
| #34 [52634] |
| a-db.aspn.net |
| what the fuck does gosu stand for? |
| #35 1st~Kakaru[52638] |
| r38m17.cybercable.tm.fr |
Lurker drops Own ^^
(so does goon ferry)
keke |
| #36 S_Warrior[52645] |
| d5090.dtk.chello.nl |
I agree with Chinks
this br is definitely NOT a 10
a 9 maybe
and the reason was already mentioned above
1on1 on LT br's are like 90% of the total SC/BW br's
it's just not fun anymore
gosu apparently means 'skilled or some stuff like very good' in Korean language
the layout was nice though brown is not very cheerfull or actionlike =(
definitely a 8-9 br |
| #37 Flisk[52648] |
| CWIP-T-010-p-224-191.tmns.net.au |
Rocking.
10
nuff sed thx |
| #38 probe[52800] |
| 242849hfc64.tampabay.rr.com |
you're fucking godly with graphics and html setup, but i do have some things to say
enough gay korean slang
and enough ladder maps, namely dire/temple/rivarly
if you BR on maps other than that, i'd be even godlier!
reports like these make me realize why i don't br anymore;) |
| #39 Slayangel[52819] |
| pool0356.cvx29-bradley.dialup.earthlink.net |
To Hiso,
Since you respect Drefsab's sense of humor perhaps you should check out my report which he rated an 8 and its text only.
I sure am jealous of Sephh's HTML knowledge and I respect the work he must have put into the graphics of this report. In my opinion if he was truly confident this report was one of the best he wouldn't have asked for a 10. He should take the criticisms of the readers here constructively and act on them so he won't have to ask next time.
Still, if you think this report is that good you're certainly entitled to your opinion and I'm sure Sephh appreciates your compliments, implied and otherwise.
~Slay |
| #40 $h@dow[52959] |
| pdx-ppp264.pop1.net |
| I used to play non-ladder maps and now I'm playing a lot more lost temple and I find out it is a BGH on another level?, oh my oh my :) |
| #41 SlingsNArrows[53051] |
| bgm-24-95-150-230.stny.rr.com |
Sephh's reports > My reports :o(
Gj, 10, and I've never thought anyone should have received a 10 before. lol |
| #42 Dausuul[53212] |
| kiewit-pub-bp-94.dartmouth.edu |
Damn good report. My only complaint is a slight blandness. My favourite BRs are those done with a distinct personal style, like Drefsab with humour, or Heartcutter with his bad-ass attitude.
Still, this is only your second report; style will come with time, no doubt. I definitely liked the minimap pictures showing the progression of various maneuvers. It made everything crystal clear; it was really easy to understand what was going on, despite some fairly tricky strategies being used.
Great work!
--Dausuul |
Home
Forum
Starcraft Tournaments
